Menu

The 16 Best Butter Tarts in Toronto

For those looking to satisfy their sweet tooth in Toronto, butter tarts are a must-try dessert. These delicious treats feature a flaky pastry shell filled with a gooey combination of butter, sugar, and sometimes nuts or raisins. Whether you prefer yours plain and classic or with a unique twist, there are plenty of bakeries and cafes throughout the city that serve up mouth-watering butter tarts.

From traditional bakeries to trendy cafes, Toronto offers a variety of options for butter tart enthusiasts to explore. Whether you're a local looking for your next favorite spot or a visitor seeking a taste of Canadian culinary tradition, this list of the 16 Best Butter Tarts in Toronto is sure to help you find the perfect treat.

How this list is ordered

To put together this guide to butter tarts in Toronto, we looked at what each business really focuses on, how its customers rate it over time and what it shows about its work on its own channels. The order is ours and we review it regularly.

Featured positions are clearly marked and only offered to businesses that already earned their place in the guide.

Top 3Every optionMapChoosing well

Where to start

Pick one to read the short summary below.

#1
Tartistry
4.8233 reviews
#2
Gerrard St. Bakery
4.7322 reviews
#3
Julie’s Homemade Butter Tarts
4.940 reviews

Compare the 16 local options

Tartistry, Toronto#1
Why it stands out

  • Terrific tasty tarts that are gluten-free with vegan options

  • Enjoyed a soup and corn bread with an oat latte while listening to live music

  • Best gluten-free pastries in Ontario with incredible atmosphere and live jazz

  • Special place with a great selection of pies, tarts, and hot drinks

Tartistry

4.8233 reviews
1252 The Queensway, Etobicoke, ON M8Z 1S2, Canada

Tartistry Cafe is a charming spot in Etobicoke that offers a variety of delightful tarts and other treats. The cafe provides delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options for their customers to enjoy. With a great tea selection and live performances, customers can relax and unwind in a casual and cosy atmosphere.

Customer reviews rave about the delectable tarts and the friendly staff at Tartistry. Here are some key points from the reviews:

Visit Tartistry for a unique and enjoyable cafe experience that mixes delicious treats with a cozy ambiance.

Gerrard St. Bakery, Toronto#2
Why it stands out

  • Delicious butter tarts that are a definite must-try.

  • Great customer service with friendly and helpful staff.

  • Wide variety of pastries to choose from, all freshly baked and consistently fantastic.

  • Ambiance that exudes warmth and charm, making every visit a delightful experience.

Gerrard St. Bakery

4.7322 reviews
635 Gerrard St E, Toronto, ON M4M 1Y2, Canada

Gerrard St. Bakery is a charming bakery located in Toronto that offers a variety of delicious treats to satisfy any sweet tooth. The bakery provides delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway options for their customers' convenience. They accept credit cards as a form of payment. The entrance is wheelchair-accessible, ensuring that everyone can enjoy their delectable pastries.

With a stellar rating of 4.7 from 322 reviews, Gerrard St. Bakery has garnered a positive reputation among customers. Some key points from the reviews include:

Customers have praised the bakery for its incredibly delicious pastries and amazing service, with many expressing their intent to return for more of their delectable treats. If you're in the area, don't miss out on the opportunity to indulge in the delightful offerings at Gerrard St. Bakery!

Julie’s Homemade Butter Tarts, Toronto#3
Why it stands out

  • The tarts are perfectly baked, not too sweet, with a flaky pastry crust.

  • The butter tarts taste homemade with love and care.

  • Customers appreciate the friendly service and easy navigation to the stand.

Julie’s Homemade Butter Tarts

4.940 reviews
8 Beare Rd, Scarborough, ON M1X 1P6, Canada

Julie’s Homemade Butter Tarts is a delightful pastry shop located in Scarborough, ON, Canada. Their delectable butter tarts have garnered rave reviews from satisfied customers. Mama of Boys mentioned that every tart was equally delicious, even the one "that doesn't like butter tarts." Another customer, Julie Tu, enjoyed the different flavors, with favorites being pecan and coconut.

With a rating of 4.9 and positive reviews, Julie’s Homemade Butter Tarts is a must-visit for pastry enthusiasts looking for delicious treats.

Sweetie Pie (Harbord), Toronto#4
Why it stands out

  • The pies are mind-blowing, especially the butter tarts.

  • Staff is amazing and super friendly.

  • The apple pies and cookies are baked with care and love.

  • The pecan pie is perfect and a must-try.

Sweetie Pie (Harbord)

4.6163 reviews
326 Harbord St, Toronto, ON M6G 1H1, Canada

Sweetie Pie (Harbord) is a delightful bakery in Toronto that offers a wide range of mouthwatering treats. Customers rave about the friendly and accommodating staff who make the experience truly special. The pie crusts are described as awesome, while the butter tarts are melt-in-your-mouth delicious. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

If you're looking for a place to satisfy your sweet tooth, Sweetie Pie (Harbord) is the perfect spot to indulge in delectable pastries and desserts.

Harbord Bakery, Toronto#5
Why it stands out

  • Delicious breads, cakes, pastries, and more are a hit with the community

  • Cozy, straightforward bakery with a variety of options like biscottis, bagels, and butter tarts

  • Great place for fresh bread and baked goods, with exceptional customer service

  • Extraordinary selection of artisanal bread and decadent pastries, paired with unparalleled customer service

Harbord Bakery

4.5511 reviews
115 Harbord St, Toronto, ON M5S 1G7, Canada

Harbord Bakery is a beloved establishment in Toronto offering a wide range of baked goods and treats. With a 4.5-star rating from over 500 reviews, it's clear that customers keep coming back for more. Here are some key points from recent reviews:

Whether you're in the mood for a simple loaf of bread or a decadent pastry, Harbord Bakery has something to satisfy every craving. Visit them today for a truly delightful bakery experience.

Absolute Bakery & Cafe, Toronto#6
Why it stands out

  • The croissants and danishes are highly recommended and always fresh out of the oven.

  • Some customers have mentioned that the chocolate croissant is the best they have ever eaten.

  • The bakery offers a fantastic variety of pastries, both sweet and savory, including dairy-free options.

  • Customers appreciate the personal touch of this family-run business and the affordable prices.

Absolute Bakery & Cafe

4.5477 reviews
589 Parliament St, Toronto, ON M4X 1P8, Canada

Absolute Bakery & Cafe is a charming neighborhood bakery in Toronto that has garnered a solid reputation with a rating of 4.5 stars from 477 reviews. Customers rave about the friendly service and the mouth-watering selection of pastries and pies. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

If you are looking for a delightful bakery experience with a mix of classic and unique pastries, Absolute Bakery & Cafe is the place to be.

Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop, Toronto#7
Why it stands out

  • Nice bakery with freshly baked goods, including breads, pastries, and cakes. The service can be a bit rushed, but overall, the products are worth a visit.

  • The chocolate cheesecake was a hit at a birthday celebration. The desserts are not overly sweet, making them perfect for those who prefer milder flavors.

  • While the savory items like samosas and bagels were decent, they lacked flavor, and the sweet treats did not stand out. Quick service and reasonable prices earn this bakery a solid 3-star rating.

  • Customers love the fantastic selection of soups, breads, and sweet treats at Phipps Bakery. The sourdough bread, challah bread, and minestrone soup are highly recommended. The butter tart is a must-try, although availability could be improved.

Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop

4.5407 reviews
420 Eglinton Ave W, Toronto, ON M5N 1A2, Canada

Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop is a charming bakery located in Toronto, Canada, offering a delightful selection of baked goods, pastries, cakes, and more. The bakery provides various service options such as delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and takeaway. Customers can enjoy a wheelchair-accessible entrance and breakfast options. Accepted payment methods include credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Customers rave about their experiences at Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop:

Mabel's Bakery & Specialty Foods, Toronto#8
Why it stands out

  • Customers appreciate the friendly staff and quick service.

  • Some reviews mention the high quality of products like pecan cake slice and mini cheesecake.

  • There are comments about price hikes and a decline in food quality from some loyal customers.

  • Audrey, one of the workers, is praised for providing a warm and pleasant atmosphere.

Mabel's Bakery & Specialty Foods

4.5290 reviews
746 St Clair Ave W, Toronto, ON M6C 1B5, Canada

Mabel's Bakery & Specialty Foods is a quaint bakery located in Toronto, offering a variety of delicious baked goods and specialty foods. Customers can enjoy services such as Kerbside pickup and In-store shopping. The bakery is known for its LGBTQ+ friendly environment and accepts various payment methods including credit cards and debit cards.

Sweetie Pie (Queen St.), Toronto#9
Why it stands out

  • Literally my favourite place on Queen for a little treat. Super sweet staff and adorable shop. Best chocolate chip cookie in the city.

  • Pies are baked perfectly with buttery, flakey crusts. Savoury pies are delicious and full, while fruit pies have nice chunks of fruit.

  • Fresh bread and friendly service make for a delicious lunch. Local small business beats chain operators any day.

  • The vegan pot pie is highly recommended, especially the mushroom flavor. Free butter tart was the perfect sweet treat.

Sweetie Pie (Queen St.)

4.665 reviews
654 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1E5, Canada

Sweetie Pie (Queen St.) is a charming pie shop located at 654 Queen St W in Toronto. They offer a variety of services including delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and takeaway. Customers can enjoy convenient payment options such as credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

With a rating of 4.6 stars based on 65 reviews, Sweetie Pie has received high praise from customers.

Customers rave about the delicious treats at Sweetie Pie, from buttery pies to gourmet cookies. Whether you're in the mood for a savory pot pie or a sweet tart, this cozy shop is sure to satisfy your cravings.

Eric's Handcrafted Butter Tarts, Toronto#10
Why it stands out

  • The filling is not too sweet and has a strong flavor of caramelized maple syrup.

  • The crust is thin and firm, yet melts in your mouth, holding the tart together perfectly.

  • Customers love the variety of flavors offered, such as Walnut, Pecan, and Classic plain.

  • One reviewer even mentioned that Eric's butter tarts are the best they have ever tasted, and they highly recommend trying them.

Eric's Handcrafted Butter Tarts

4.919 reviews

Open 24 hours

PICKUPS ON FRIDAYS BY APPOINTMENT ONLY, 77 Seventh St, Etobicoke, ON M8V 3B3, Canada

Eric's Handcrafted Butter Tarts is a renowned Wholesale bakery located in Etobicoke, Canada. They offer a variety of delicious butter tarts made with all-natural ingredients. Customers have left glowing reviews raving about the quality and taste of Eric's butter tarts.

These positive reviews highlight the superior quality and taste of Eric's Handcrafted Butter Tarts. If you are a fan of butter tarts, be sure to visit and try their delicious creations!

Sweetie Pie (Distillery District), Toronto#11
Why it stands out

  • A hidden gem in the bustling Distillery District, known for its delicious sweet and savory pies.

  • Customers appreciate the friendly service and the wide array of options, including small individual pies and large pies.

  • The pie house is pet-friendly, welcoming furry friends with water and treats, creating a warm and inviting environment.

  • Highlights include the incredible blueberry pie, perfect crust, and attentive staff, making Sweetie Pie a top choice for pie enthusiasts.

Sweetie Pie (Distillery District)

4.5139 reviews
6 Case Goods Lane, Toronto, ON M5A 3C4, Canada

Sweetie Pie (Distillery District) is a charming bakery located in Toronto, Canada, offering a variety of pies, cookies, and more. Customers have praised the delightful flavors and cozy atmosphere of this establishment, making it a must-visit destination for those with a sweet tooth.

Belle's Bakery, Toronto#12
Why it stands out

  • One customer mentioned that the chicken tikka empanada was exceptional and probably the best thing they had eaten in weeks. They also recommended trying the pastel de Nata.

  • Another visitor praised the bakery for its wide selection of dessert options, highlighting the Cannoli, poppyseed bagel with cream cheese, and hot chocolate as favorites.

  • A different review suggested that Belle's Bakery has fresh food, fair prices, and outstanding service. Their top recommendations included the tarts, carrot cake, and empanadas.

  • However, some customers pointed out areas for improvement, like the freshness of ingredients in sandwiches and overly buttery croissants.

Belle's Bakery

4.4178 reviews
262 Dupont St, Toronto, ON M5R 1V7, Canada

Belle's Bakery is a charming bakery located in Toronto, offering a variety of delicious pastries and baked goods. With a rating of 4.4 stars, customers have raved about their tasty treats and friendly service.

Whether you're in the mood for a sweet treat or a savory snack, Belle's Bakery has something for everyone. Make sure to stop by and indulge in their delectable offerings!

Tartistry, Toronto#13
Why it stands out

  • Customers love the varied selection of sweet tarts and savory pies available at Tartistry.

  • The vegan options are a hit with customers looking for delicious and plant-based treats.

  • Visitors appreciate the friendly and helpful staff who make their experience at Tartistry even more enjoyable.

  • The gluten-free desserts receive high praise from customers who are looking for allergy-friendly options.

Tartistry

5.05 reviews
1 Trinity St Container #2, Toronto, ON M5A 1G3, Canada

Tartistry is a charming dessert shop located in Toronto, Canada. This delightful shop offers a variety of mouth-watering sweet tarts and savory pies that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Customers rave about the delicious treats and friendly service they receive at Tartistry.

Don't miss out on a visit to Tartistry to indulge in their delectable treats and experience exceptional service!

Almond Butterfly Bakeshop & Cafe, Toronto#14
Why it stands out

  • Warm and inviting atmosphere with friendly staff.

  • Delicious gluten-free options that are full of flavor.

  • Extensive selection of vegan baked goods that exceed expectations.

  • Top-tier cookie experience that stands out among others.

Almond Butterfly Bakeshop & Cafe

4.5824 reviews
100 Harbord St, Toronto, ON M5S 1G6, Canada

Almond Butterfly Bakeshop & Cafe is a charming spot in Toronto offering a variety of services to cater to their customers' needs. From Outdoor seating to No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in options, they ensure a seamless dining experience.

This quaint cafe is known for its Great tea selection as highlighted in their service. They also offer an array of culinary delights such as Coffee, Healthy options, Organic dishes, Prepared foods, Small plates, Vegan options, and Vegetarian options to please all palates.

Customer reviews rave about the delectable treats available at Almond Butterfly. Some key points from reviews include:

If you're in the mood for a cozy cafe experience with a focus on quality and taste, Almond Butterfly Bakeshop & Cafe is the place to be. Visit them soon to savor their delightful offerings!

Butter Baker Market Café, Toronto#15
Why it stands out

  • Tiny space to dine in, but not too long of a wait during brunch

  • Quality breakfast options, with exceptional croissants and cookies

  • Excellent pastries and baked goods that keep customers coming back

  • Great customer service, cozy atmosphere, and delicious treats

Butter Baker Market Café

4.11,035 reviews
120 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M5G 1C3, Canada

Butter Baker Market Café is a charming bakery located in Toronto that specializes in delectable pastries and cakes. The bakery offers various service options such as delivery, in-store pick-up, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers can enjoy a cozy breakfast experience at the café and indulge in a wide selection of baked goods.

With a rating of 4.1 stars based on 1035 reviews, customers have shared their positive experiences at Butter Baker Market Café. Here are some key points from the reviews:

Don't miss the opportunity to experience the delightful treats and warm hospitality at Butter Baker Market Café!

Sweetie Pie (First Canadian Place), Toronto#16
Why it stands out

  • Moist and not overly sweet cupcakes

  • Delectable beef short rib and chocolate bourbon pecan pie

  • Massive and delicious cookies with great drinks

  • Large variety of options, but some items may be underwhelming

Sweetie Pie (First Canadian Place)

4.119 reviews
100 King St W, Toronto, ON M5X 1A9, Canada

Sweetie Pie (First Canadian Place) is a delightful Bakery located in Toronto, Canada. They offer a range of Service options including Delivery, In-store pick-up, and Takeaway for convenience. Customers can enjoy these services while making Credit card payments.

With a solid Rating of 4.1 out of 5, Sweetie Pie has garnered positive feedback from its patrons. Here are some key points from recent reviews:

Customers have praised the bakery for its quality baked goods and friendly service. Visit Sweetie Pie to satisfy your sweet cravings and indulge in some delectable treats!

The essentials in one table

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1Tartistry 4.8233
#2Gerrard St. Bakery 4.7322
#3Julie’s Homemade Butter Tarts 4.940
#4Sweetie Pie (Harbord) 4.6163
#5Harbord Bakery 4.5511
#6Absolute Bakery & Cafe 4.5477
#7Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop 4.5407
#8Mabel's Bakery & Specialty Foods 4.5290
#9Sweetie Pie (Queen St.) 4.665
#10Eric's Handcrafted Butter Tarts 4.919
#11Sweetie Pie (Distillery District) 4.5139
#12Belle's Bakery 4.4178
#13Tartistry 5.05
#14Almond Butterfly Bakeshop & Cafe 4.5824
#15Butter Baker Market Café 4.11,035
#16Sweetie Pie (First Canadian Place) 4.119

Business owner or manager?

List or claim my business

Map of Butter Tarts in Toronto

Are you on the hunt for the tastiest butter tarts in Toronto? Look no further! Our meticulously researched map should guide your stomach on a sweet tour through the city. From the most traditional tarts to reinvented classics, you'll find an array of delightful spots. Here's our comprehensive map of all the butter tarts in Toronto.

How to compare Butter Tarts in Toronto

  1. Location: find butter tarts near you.
  2. Price: compare prices to fit your budget.
  3. Flavors: explore a variety of fillings and toppings.
  4. Reviews: read customer feedback to make an informed choice.
  5. Special features: consider unique offerings such as gluten-free or vegan options.

Your questions answered

What are butter tarts?

Butter tarts are a classic Canadian pastry made with a sweet filling of butter, sugar, syrup, and eggs, baked in a flaky pastry shell. The filling of the tart is typically gooey and slightly runny, with a caramel-like flavor. Butter tarts can also include additional ingredients such as raisins, nuts, or chocolate chips. They are often enjoyed as a dessert or sweet treat, either on their own or with a dollop of whipped cream or a scoop of ice cream.

Where can I find the best butter tarts in Toronto?

If you're looking for the best butter tarts in Toronto, there are several bakeries and pastry shops in the city known for their delicious tarts. Some popular places to try include: Bunner's Bakeshop: Known for their vegan pastries, Bunner's offers a delectable butter tart that is a fan favorite. Dish Cooking Studio: This culinary studio offers a unique twist on the traditional butter tart, with flavors like bacon bourbon and peanut butter chocolate. Le Dolci: Offering a variety of sweet treats, Le Dolci's butter tarts are a must-try for any dessert lover.

Are there any bakeries in Toronto that specialize in butter tarts?

Yes, there are several bakeries in Toronto that specialize in butter tarts and other sweet treats. These bakeries often focus on creating high-quality, handmade pastries with a traditional or innovative twist. Some popular butter tart bakeries in Toronto include: Peter's Fine Bakery: A family-owned bakery known for its butter tarts and other pastries made from scratch. Dolly's on Queen: This cozy bakery offers a variety of butter tart flavors, including classic, pecan, and maple bacon. The Sweet Oven: Specializing in custom cakes and desserts, The Sweet Oven also makes delicious butter tarts in different sizes and flavors.

Can I order butter tarts for delivery in Toronto?

Yes, many bakeries and pastry shops in Toronto offer delivery services for their butter tarts and other baked goods. Some establishments have their own delivery drivers, while others use third-party delivery platforms like Uber Eats or DoorDash. Ordering butter tarts for delivery is a convenient way to satisfy your sweet tooth without leaving the comfort of your home. Be sure to check the delivery options and fees when placing your order.

Other related guides

The 11 Best Salads in TorontoThe 16 Best Croissants in TorontoThe 16 Best Cake Bakeries in Toronto