Menu

The 20 Best Tenant Insurance in Toronto

Looking for tenant insurance in Toronto to protect your belongings and provide liability coverage? Whether you're renting an apartment, condo, or house, having tenant insurance gives you peace of mind knowing you're covered in case of theft, fire, or other unforeseen events.

With so many options available in the Toronto area, it can be overwhelming to choose the right policy for your needs. That's why it's important to compare the different services and key points offered by each provider to find the best option for you.

Explore the list below to find the top tenant insurance providers in Toronto and make sure your rental property is properly protected.

How this list is ordered

To put together this guide to tenant insurance in Toronto, we looked at what each business really focuses on, how its customers rate it over time and what it shows about its work on its own channels. The order is ours and we review it regularly.

Featured positions are clearly marked and only offered to businesses that already earned their place in the guide.

Top 3Every optionMapChoosing well

Compare the 20 local options

Leibel Insurance Group, Toronto#1
Why it stands out
  • Customers rave about the professionalism and expertise of the brokers, especially Jennifer Gignac, who is praised for her ability to find affordable policies with the same coverage as larger insurance companies.

  • Many clients appreciate how efficient and seamless the process is when working with Leibel Insurance Group, making it a stress-free experience.

  • Customers also highlight how knowledgeable and helpful the brokers are in providing all the necessary information and answering any questions promptly.

  • The attention to detail and personalized service that clients receive sets Leibel Insurance Group apart, making them a go-to choice for insurance needs.

Leibel Insurance Group

5.0175 reviews
401 Bay St. Suite #1600, Toronto, ON M5H 2Y4, Canada

Leibel Insurance Group is a top-notch insurance broker located in Toronto, Canada. They offer a range of services to ensure customers get the coverage they need at an affordable price. With a 5.0 rating, it's clear that their clients are more than satisfied with the level of service they provide.

With an emphasis on excellent service and customer satisfaction, Leibel Insurance Group is the perfect choice for anyone looking for a reliable and trustworthy insurance broker.

RH Insurance Inc., Toronto#2
Why it stands out
  • Professionalism and personalized service are top-notch.

  • Quick response times and seamless processes were greatly appreciated.

  • Significant cost savings and competitive rates were achieved.

  • Highly recommended for various insurance needs.

RH Insurance Inc.

4.9290 reviews
20 Queen St W Suite 1101, Toronto, ON M5H 3R3, Canada

RH Insurance Inc. is a reputable insurance agency situated in Toronto, Canada. They offer a range of service options including Online appointments for the convenience of their clients. Moreover, they provide Wheelchair-accessible car park to ensure accessibility for all customers.

With a stellar rating of 4.9 stars based on 290 reviews, RH Insurance Inc. has garnered high praise from satisfied clients. Here are some key points from the customer reviews:

Customers like Sarah Morales, Ankur Taxali, Bob McCallion, Sherri Zavitz, Zunair M. Khan, Marc Hasserjian, Susanne Markowski, and Vick Jogarasan have all shared their positive experiences and satisfaction with the exceptional service provided by RH Insurance Inc. Consider reaching out to them for your insurance requirements.

Zensurance, Toronto#3
Why it stands out
  • Customers appreciate the professionalism and quick response from the dedicated team at Zensurance.

  • The customized solutions offered by Zensurance ensure that clients receive the exact coverage they require at a fair price.

  • Zensurance stands out for its excellent customer service, with brokers going above and beyond to assist clients, even after work hours.

  • Clients value the ease of working with Zensurance, highlighting the knowledge and efficiency of the agents in providing the best insurance options for their businesses.

Zensurance

4.83,765 reviews
200 University Ave #1301, Toronto, ON M5H 3C6, Canada

Zensurance is a reputable insurance agency located in Toronto, offering a wide range of insurance services tailored to meet each client's specific needs. With a rating of 4.8 based on 3765 reviews, it's evident that customers are highly satisfied with the exceptional service and coverage provided by Zensurance.

Whether you are a new business owner looking for comprehensive insurance coverage or an established business seeking personalized solutions, Zensurance is the go-to agency for all your insurance needs.

Neil Thakkar, Toronto#4
Why it stands out
  • Professionalism and dedication in finding the best insurance quotes

  • Exceptional knowledge of the insurance industry and prompt responses to inquiries

  • Reliable and excellent service, even for individuals with previous incidents on their record

  • Streamlined process, tailored policy options, and commitment to customer satisfaction

Neil Thakkar

4.9133 reviews
1050 Markham Rd, Toronto, ON M1H 2Y5, Canada

Neil Thakkar is a renowned Insurance broker in Toronto that offers a range of services to meet all your insurance needs. With a stellar rating of 4.9 stars, based on 133 reviews, it's clear that customers trust and appreciate the services provided.

If you're looking for reliable insurance services, look no further than Neil Thakkar!

Reliable Insurance Brokers Inc, Toronto#5
Why it stands out
  • Knowledgeable and helpful staff, such as Adnan, who goes above and beyond to provide the best insurance solutions.

  • Competitive pricing and unbeatable quotes that make switching insurance policies a no-brainer.

  • Quick and efficient service that eases the stress of dealing with insurance matters.

Reliable Insurance Brokers Inc

4.9129 reviews
112 Pacific Ave, Toronto, ON M6P 2P3, Canada

Reliable Insurance Brokers Inc is a top-rated insurance broker in Toronto, offering exceptional services to its clients. With a stellar rating of 4.9, customers rave about the personalized and knowledgeable assistance they receive. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Whether you're a new policyholder or looking to switch providers, Reliable Insurance Brokers Inc is the go-to choice for all your insurance needs. Contact them today for a quote and experience their outstanding service firsthand.

DirectRate.ca, Toronto#6
Why it stands out
  • Customers appreciate the clear and informative assistance provided by the staff.

  • The competitive rates offered by the business are highly praised.

  • Individuals value the professionalism and personalized service received from the team.

  • The prompt and efficient responses to inquiries make the overall experience with DirectRate.ca highly satisfactory.

DirectRate.ca

4.9144 reviews
1910 Yonge St Suite 401B, Toronto, ON M4S 3B2, Canada

DirectRate.ca is a trusted insurance broker located in Toronto, Canada. The business offers various services and features to meet the insurance needs of its customers. With a rating of 4.9, it is evident that customers are highly satisfied with the exceptional service provided.

If you are looking for a reliable insurance broker with excellent customer reviews, DirectRate.ca is the place to go. Contact them today to fulfill all your insurance needs and experience top-notch service.

KASE Insurance, Toronto#7
Why it stands out
  • Responsive and intelligent customer service

  • Competitive rates with comprehensive coverage

  • Reliable and trustworthy team

  • Efficient and knowledgeable staff

KASE Insurance

4.8348 reviews
145 Front St E Suite 207, Toronto, ON M5A 1E3, Canada

KASE Insurance is a top-notch insurance broker in Toronto, known for their exceptional service and competitive rates. Customers rave about the timely and intelligent responses they receive, no matter who they deal with in the company. Some key points from customer reviews include:

Whether you need online appointments or on-site services, KASE Insurance has you covered. They also provide wheelchair-accessible car park and entrance for those with accessibility needs. Trust KASE Insurance for all your insurance needs and experience peace of mind with their reliable service.

Square One Insurance Services, Toronto#8
Why it stands out
  • Eran provided thorough policy details and excellent customer service.

  • Eran offered exceptional service, providing detailed explanations and great prices.

  • The agency responded promptly to a claim and arranged for quick onsite repair.

  • Newcomers praised the fair prices and polite explanations given by the staff.

Square One Insurance Services

4.72,532 reviews
1 Dundas St W #2500, Toronto, ON M5G 1Z3, Canada

Square One Insurance Services is a reputable home insurance agency located in Toronto. They offer various service options and strive to provide excellent customer service to their clients. The agency is wheelchair-accessible, ensuring that all clients can easily access their services.

With a rating of 4.7 stars based on 2532 reviews, customers have shared their positive experiences with the agency:

These reviews highlight the agency's commitment to delivering top-notch service and expertise to their clients.

ThinkInsure, Toronto#9
Why it stands out
  • Professional and courteous service from knowledgeable brokers

  • Ability to find affordable insurance plans, even for high-risk individuals

  • Above and beyond customer service, with brokers going the extra mile to assist

ThinkInsure

4.71,394 reviews
5700 Yonge St Suite 1900, Toronto, ON M2M 4K2, Canada

ThinkInsure is a reputable insurance broker located in Toronto, Canada. They offer a variety of services to cater to their clients' needs. One standout feature is the ability to schedule online appointments, making it convenient for busy individuals to seek insurance advice.

Customers have left glowing reviews for ThinkInsure, highlighting the exceptional service they received. Here are some key points from their feedback:

The dedicated team at ThinkInsure, exemplified by brokers like Todd Allen, Neil Sullivan, and Sean Maitland, ensures that every client receives personalized attention and finds the best insurance solutions. Whether you need assistance with auto, home, or commercial insurance, ThinkInsure is there to help. Contact them today to experience top-notch service and expert advice.

Co-operators, Toronto#10
Why it stands out
  • Professional and knowledgeable staff, particularly highlighting Amber's exceptional customer service and expertise in providing great deals on auto, home, and life insurance policies.

  • Positive experiences with the customer service representatives, seamless claims process, and competitive rates offered by the agency.

  • Highly recommended insurance advisor, Supreet, for her exceptional help in finding the best auto and home insurance policies that suit the clients' budget and coverage needs.

Co-operators

4.8138 reviews
1029 King St W Unit 30, Toronto, ON M6K 3M9, Canada

Co-operators is a reliable insurance agency located in Toronto, Canada, offering a variety of insurance policies and services to meet their customers' needs. They provide service options such as online appointments and on-site services, making it convenient for clients to access their services. The agency ensures accessibility by offering wheelchair-accessible car park and entrance. And for better planning, appointments are required to provide personalized attention to each client.

With a remarkable rating of 4.8 and 138 reviews, Co-operators has received glowing feedback from satisfied customers. Here are some key points from their reviews:

These reviews reflect the dedication and commitment of the team at Co-operators to provide top-notch insurance services to their valued clients.

Johnson Insurance, Toronto#11
Why it stands out
  • Highly trained customer service team

  • Knowledgeable and patient agents

  • Easy to understand processes

  • Quick response times

Johnson Insurance

4.7715 reviews
18 Spadina Rd Suite 100, Toronto, ON M5R 2S7, Canada

Johnson Insurance is a reputable insurance agency located in the heart of Toronto, Canada. They offer a wide range of service options to cater to their clients' needs. Customers have praised Johnson Insurance for their exceptional customer service and professionalism.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

The positive feedback from satisfied clients highlights the dedication of Johnson Insurance to providing top-notch services to their customers. If you are looking for reliable and trustworthy insurance coverage, consider giving Johnson Insurance a call today!

Mitch Insurance Brokers, Toronto#12
Why it stands out
  • Outstanding customer service provided by Katie Young, making the insurance process seamless and stress-free.

  • Daniela's clear description of terms and options, along with efficient follow-up calls, left a lasting impression on a customer.

  • Josh's fast and knowledgeable service resulted in an amazing premium for a customer, who highly recommends dealing with him.

Mitch Insurance Brokers

4.7465 reviews
110 Yonge St, Toronto, ON M5C 1T4, Canada

Mitch Insurance Brokers is a reputable insurance broker located in Toronto. They offer a range of services to meet the insurance needs of their clients. Customers have highlighted a few key points in their reviews:

These positive reviews reflect the professionalism and dedication of the team at Mitch Insurance Brokers. With services like on-site options and wheelchair-accessible parking, customers can expect a comprehensive and accessible insurance experience. Visit their website for more information or give them a call to schedule an appointment.

Duuo by Co-operators, Toronto#13
Why it stands out
  • Customers appreciate the quick and easy process of obtaining insurance policies.

  • The rates offered by Duuo are reasonable and competitive in the market.

  • The company provides excellent customer service and support, making the entire experience pleasant and hassle-free for clients.

  • Customers value the convenience and simplicity of using Duuo's services, emphasizing the straightforwardness of the website and the application process.

Duuo by Co-operators

4.7253 reviews
1 York St Suite 1400, Toronto, ON M5J 0B6, Canada

Duuo by Co-operators is a renowned insurance company located in Toronto, Canada. They offer a wide range of services tailored to meet their customers' needs. Customers have praised the company for its efficiency, affordability, and simplicity in obtaining insurance coverage.

With a stellar rating of 4.7, Duuo by Co-operators is a top choice for individuals seeking reliable and affordable insurance solutions.

Humberview Insurance Brokers Ltd., Toronto#14
Why it stands out
  • Customers appreciate the personalized and attentive service provided by the knowledgeable staff.

  • The team is responsive, efficient, and professional, making the insurance process easy and hassle-free.

  • Clients value the thoroughness and expertise of the professionals at Humberview, ensuring that they receive the best insurance coverage for their specific needs.

  • Many customers highly recommend Humberview Insurance Brokers Ltd. for their outstanding service and competitive prices.

Humberview Insurance Brokers Ltd.

4.7109 reviews
339 Roncesvalles Ave, Toronto, ON M6R 2M8, Canada

Humberview Insurance Brokers Ltd. is a well-known insurance broker located in Toronto, Canada. They offer a wide range of insurance services to meet the diverse needs of their clients.

Some of the services and features that set them apart include personalized insurance policies tailored to individual needs, quick and efficient customer service, and a team of knowledgeable professionals who are always ready to help.

With a rating of 4.7 based on 109 reviews, it's clear that customers are extremely satisfied with the service they receive at Humberview Insurance Brokers Ltd. Here are some key points summarized from the reviews:

If you are in need of reliable and personalized insurance solutions, Humberview Insurance Brokers Ltd. is the place to go. Contact them today to discuss your insurance needs and experience their exceptional service firsthand.

Ratesdotca, Toronto#15
Why it stands out
  • A customer saved over $200 by choosing Ratesdotca over other providers.

  • Friendly staff and short call wait times make the customer experience pleasant.

  • Helpful brokers educate customers on insurance choices and find great prices.

  • Quick response times and significant savings on insurance premiums are consistently reported.

Ratesdotca

4.62,486 reviews
225 King St W Suite 1000, Toronto, ON M5V 3M2, Canada

Ratesdotca is an auto insurance agency located in Toronto that offers exceptional services to its customers. With a rating of 4.6, based on 2486 reviews, it is clear that customers are highly satisfied with the service provided. Some key points highlighted in the reviews include:

The agency offers convenient online appointments for customers and is LGBTQ+ friendly, catering to a diverse range of clients. The positive feedback from satisfied customers speaks volumes about the quality and effectiveness of the services provided by Ratesdotca.

LowestRates.ca, Toronto#16
Why it stands out
  • Brandon provided excellent customer service, responding in a timely manner and ensuring a seamless experience.

  • Juliana made a customer's day by going above and beyond, showing kindness and empathy.

  • Some users encountered delays in the process but appreciated the polite and friendly service.

  • Many praised the cost-saving opportunities, with one customer noting savings of $120 a month with the help of Natasha Gilbert.

LowestRates.ca

4.61,297 reviews
1910 Yonge St Suite 401, Toronto, ON M4S 3B2, Canada

LowestRates.ca is a renowned corporate office in Toronto, known for its exceptional services in providing insurance quotes. Customers have left glowing reviews, highlighting a few key points:

With a stellar rating of 4.6, LowestRates.ca continues to be a top choice for insurance needs in the area. Visit their website to experience their outstanding service today!

LNearby option
#17
Why it stands out
  • Exceptional customer service and personalized attention

  • Efficient and quick handling of insurance policies

  • Expertise and clear communication from brokers

  • Highly recommended for anyone looking for insurance

Levitt Insurance Brokers Ltd

4.7163 reviews
5050 Dufferin St Unit 119, North York, ON M3H 5T5, Canada

Levitt Insurance Brokers Ltd is an auto insurance agency dedicated to providing exceptional service to their clients. The team at Levitt goes above and beyond to ensure that each customer receives personalized attention and expert advice when it comes to selecting the right insurance policy.

With a rating of 4.7 based on 163 reviews, it's clear that customers have had overwhelmingly positive experiences with Levitt Insurance. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Whether you are in need of auto insurance or looking to bundle policies for added savings, Levitt Insurance Brokers Ltd is the go-to agency for reliable and trustworthy service. Contact them today to see how they can help you with your insurance needs.

InsuranceHotline.com, Toronto#18
Why it stands out
  • Customers appreciate the helpful and informative service provided by the agents.

  • The team is knowledgeable, efficient, and friendly, making the process smooth and hassle-free for clients.

  • Clients have reported significant savings on their insurance policies after using the services of InsuranceHotline.com.

  • The agency has received numerous 5-star reviews praising the staff for their professionalism and dedication to helping customers find the best insurance options.

InsuranceHotline.com

4.6485 reviews
225 King St W Suite 1000, Toronto, ON M5V 3M2, Canada

InsuranceHotline.com is a top-rated auto insurance agency located in Toronto, Canada. The agency offers excellent customer service and provides quotes quickly to help clients save money on their insurance policies.

If you are looking for a reliable and customer-centric auto insurance agency, InsuranceHotline.com is the place to go!

Jamie Grabell Desjardins Insurance Agent, Toronto#19
Why it stands out
  • Fast and amazing service, with excellent customer service.

  • Professional, caring, and accommodating team members who go above and beyond.

  • Helpful and knowledgeable staff that provide prompt assistance and great value for money.

  • Outstanding service for both personal and business insurance needs, demonstrating dependability and excellent customer service.

Jamie Grabell Desjardins Insurance Agent

4.848 reviews
1315 Lawrence Ave E Ste 205, North York, ON M3A 3R3, Canada

Jamie Grabell Desjardins Insurance Agent is a reputable auto insurance agency located in North York, ON. The agency offers a range of service options, including online appointments and on-site services. Accessibility is also a priority, with a wheelchair-accessible car park and entrance available for all clients. With a stellar rating of 4.8 out of 5 based on 48 reviews, it's clear that customers are highly satisfied with the services provided.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Customers praise the team for their professionalism and knowledge, emphasizing the great value they receive. Whether you're looking for assistance with insurance needs or have questions about coverage, Jamie Grabell Desjardins Insurance Agent comes highly recommended by satisfied clients.

Intact Insurance, Toronto#20
Why it stands out
  • Customers have faced challenges with claims processing and communication, leading to delays and frustration.

  • Some clients have highlighted issues with paperwork and billing practices, which have resulted in unexpected charges.

  • On the positive side, some customers have commended the compassionate and informed service they received during challenging times, appreciating the caring approach.

Intact Insurance

3.8737 reviews
700 University Ave, Toronto, ON M5G 0A1, Canada

Intact Insurance is a trustworthy insurance agency located in Toronto, Canada. They offer a range of services to cater to their customers' needs, including personal insurance options. The business prioritizes Accessibility with Wheelchair-accessible car park and Wheelchair-accessible entrance for customers with special needs.

Customer reviews reflect a mix of experiences, with some customers expressing dissatisfaction and others praising their service. Here are some key points summarized from the reviews:

Overall, Intact Insurance strives to provide quality insurance services to its customers, with a focus on customer care and accessibility. If you're looking for insurance coverage in Toronto, they might be worth considering.

The essentials in one table

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1Leibel Insurance Group 5.0175
#2RH Insurance Inc. 4.9290
#3Zensurance 4.83,765
#4Neil Thakkar 4.9133
#5Reliable Insurance Brokers Inc 4.9129
#6DirectRate.ca 4.9144
#7KASE Insurance 4.8348
#8Square One Insurance Services 4.72,532
#9ThinkInsure 4.71,394
#10Co-operators 4.8138
#11Johnson Insurance 4.7715
#12Mitch Insurance Brokers 4.7465
#13Duuo by Co-operators 4.7253
#14Humberview Insurance Brokers Ltd. 4.7109
#15Ratesdotca 4.62,486
#16LowestRates.ca 4.61,297
#17Levitt Insurance Brokers Ltd 4.7163
#18InsuranceHotline.com 4.6485
#19Jamie Grabell Desjardins Insurance Agent 4.848
#20Intact Insurance 3.8737

Business owner or manager?

List or claim my business

Map of Tenant Insurance in Toronto

Understanding the landscape of tenant insurance in Toronto is essential for renters to ensure they are adequately protected. This map of all tenant insurance in Toronto provides a comprehensive overview of insurance providers across the city, highlighting the locations of companies offering renters insurance and facilitating an informed choice.

How to compare Tenant Insurance in Toronto

  1. Comprehensive coverage for personal belongings.
  2. Liability protection in case of accidents.
  3. Affordable premiums and deductibles.
  4. Responsive customer service.
  5. Flexible payment options.

Your questions answered

What does tenant insurance cover?

Tenant insurance in Toronto typically covers your personal belongings against theft, fire, vandalism, and other covered perils. It also provides liability coverage in case someone is injured in your rental unit. Additionally, tenant insurance may help cover additional living expenses if your unit becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event, such as a fire or flood. It's essential to read your policy to understand exactly what is included and excluded from coverage. Keep in mind that tenant insurance does not usually cover the building structure itself, as that is the landlord's responsibility. You may need to purchase separate insurance if you own valuable items that exceed the coverage limits of your policy. Make sure to ask your insurance provider for clarification on any areas of uncertainty.

Do I really need tenant insurance in Toronto?

Even though tenant insurance is not required by law in Toronto, it is highly recommended by professionals in the industry. Without tenant insurance, you could be financially responsible for replacing all your belongings in the event of theft, fire, or other disasters. Imagine having to start from scratch after a devastating event – the costs can add up quickly. Furthermore, tenant insurance also provides liability coverage, which can protect you in case someone is injured in your rental unit and sues you for damages. The peace of mind that comes with having tenant insurance is worth the affordable monthly premiums. It's better to be safe than sorry when it comes to protecting your belongings and finances.

How much does tenant insurance cost in Toronto?

The cost of tenant insurance in Toronto can vary depending on various factors, such as the coverage limits you choose, your deductible, the location of your rental unit, and your personal profile. On average, tenant insurance policies can range from $15 to $30 per month, making it a relatively affordable investment in your financial security. To determine the exact cost of tenant insurance for your specific situation, it's best to contact insurance providers for quotes. They can help you understand the different coverage options available and tailor a policy to meet your needs and budget. Remember that the peace of mind and protection that tenant insurance provides outweighs the cost of the premiums.

What are some ways to save on tenant insurance in Toronto?

If you're looking to save money on tenant insurance in Toronto, there are several strategies you can consider. One way is to bundle your tenant insurance with other policies, such as auto insurance, with the same provider to receive a discount. You can also increase your deductible, which can lower your premiums but means you'll pay more out of pocket in case of a claim. Another way to save on tenant insurance is to install security measures in your rental unit, such as smoke detectors, alarms, and deadbolts. This can reduce the risk of theft and damage, which may lower your insurance premiums. Additionally, maintaining a good credit score and a clean claims history can also help you secure lower rates for tenant insurance. It's worth exploring these options to find ways to save on your insurance premiums while still maintaining adequate coverage.

Other related guides