Menu

The 16 Best Pumpkin Pies in Toronto

When autumn rolls around in Toronto, the city gets painted in warm colors, and pumpkins become the star of the culinary world. Among all pumpkin delicacies, the pumpkin pie holds a special place, and Toronto boasts a delightful plethora of options for this beloved seasonal treat.

Whether you prefer a classic style, decadent variations, or even vegan-friendly versions, Toronto's bakeries will not disappoint. This guide will help you discover the 16 best pumpkin pies the city has to offer.

So get your taste buds ready, because it's time to embark on a mouthwatering journey through Toronto's best pumpkin pies.

How this list is ordered

Before ranking this guide we review each business's track record, what its customers say and how clearly it explains its work. The result is an editorial selection that we update as things change.

Featured positions are clearly marked and only offered to businesses that already earned their place in the guide.

Top 3Every optionMapChoosing well

Where to start

Pick one to read the short summary below.

#1
Sweet Trolley Bakery
4.8263 reviews
#2
The Pie Commission
4.71,044 reviews
#3
Dough Bakeshop
4.6241 reviews

Compare the 16 local options

Sweet Trolley Bakery, Toronto#1
Why it stands out

  • A traditional bakery with a wide selection of classic baked goods

  • The butter tarts have a good flavor, but there's a strange aftertaste

  • The apple pie is on the sweeter side

  • The cinnamon roll was a little dry

Sweet Trolley Bakery

4.8263 reviews
3056 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6P 1Z7, Canada

Sweet Trolley Bakery is a charming bakery located in Toronto, offering a variety of delectable treats to satisfy any sweet tooth. Customers rave about the welcoming atmosphere and delicious pastries that this bakery has to offer.

Known for its cash only policy, Sweet Trolley Bakery has been described as an old-school place where customers can find great deals on tasty treats. Whether you're in the mood for a cinnamon bun or a delicious pot pie, this bakery has something for everyone. With friendly and inviting staff like Helen, customers are sure to have a delightful experience when visiting the bakery.

So, if you're looking for a cozy bakery with mouth-watering desserts, be sure to stop by Sweet Trolley Bakery and satisfy your cravings with their delightful creations.

The Pie Commission, Toronto#2
Why it stands out

  • Customers love the generous portions and delicious fillings of the pies.

  • The buttery and flaky pastry is a crowd favorite.

  • The friendly and courteous staff make every visit a delight.

The Pie Commission

4.71,044 reviews
927 The Queensway, Etobicoke, ON M8Z 5Z7, Canada

The Pie Commission is a renowned Bakery located in Etobicoke, Canada. They offer a variety of services, including Delivery, In-store pick-up, Takeaway, and even Dine-in options. Customers rave about the delicious pies and exceptional service they receive.

If you're craving savory and sweet pies made with quality ingredients, The Pie Commission is the place to visit!

Dough Bakeshop, Toronto#3
Why it stands out

  • The carrot cake and key lime pie are must-tries with delicate decorations and amazing flavors.

  • The variety of baked goods, including peanut butter confetti squares, lemon squares, and date squares, are consistently delicious.

  • The quality of the products is top-notch with real butter used in pastries and bread.

  • The bakery is known for its friendly atmosphere and great customer service.

Dough Bakeshop

4.6241 reviews
173 Danforth Ave, Toronto, ON M4K 1N2, Canada

Dough Bakeshop is a charming bakery located in Toronto that offers a variety of delicious treats for customers to enjoy. From freshly baked bread to mouth-watering pastries, this bakery has something for everyone. The bakery provides Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, In-store pick-up, and In-store shopping options to make it convenient for customers to get their favorite baked goods.

With a stellar rating of 4.6, it's no surprise that customers rave about Dough Bakeshop. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Customers love to visit Dough Bakeshop for their delicious treats, friendly staff, and cozy atmosphere. It's a must-visit spot for anyone with a sweet tooth in Toronto.

Sweetie Pie (Harbord), Toronto#4
Why it stands out

  • The lady behind the counter was super kind, friendly, and accommodating. The pie crusts are awesome, and the butter tarts are yummy.

  • The variety of sweets was great, and the pecan pie was probably the best ever tried. Staff is super friendly, and they also offer ice cream.

  • The staff here is amazing, the pies are absolutely mind-blowing, and the butter tarts are melt-in-your-mouth delicious.

  • It is definitely on the more expensive side, but the treats are worth it. The apple pies and cookies receive a perfect 10/10.

Sweetie Pie (Harbord)

4.6163 reviews
326 Harbord St, Toronto, ON M6G 1H1, Canada

Sweetie Pie (Harbord) is a charming Bakery situated in Toronto, Canada. Customers rave about the delightful treats and exceptional service they receive at this establishment.

With a Rating of 4.6 out of 5, Sweetie Pie (Harbord) truly shines as a top-notch bakery destination for those with a sweet tooth!

Sweetie Pie (Queen St.), Toronto#5
Why it stands out

  • Literally the best chocolate chip cookie in the city.

  • Pies are baked perfectly with buttery and flakey crusts.

  • Delicious vegan options like the mushroom pot pie and free butter tart.

  • A wide variety of treat options like cookies and tarts, although some items like the Nutella stuffed cookie may be underwhelming.

Sweetie Pie (Queen St.)

4.665 reviews
654 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1E5, Canada

Sweetie Pie (Queen St.) is a charming pie shop located in Toronto, Canada, offering a variety of delicious pies and baked goods. They provide delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and takeaway options for their customers' convenience. The shop accepts credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for seamless transactions.

Customer reviews rave about the quality of the pies and the friendly service at Sweetie Pie. Some key points from their reviews include:

Visit Sweetie Pie (Queen St.) for a delightful pie experience that will surely satisfy your sweet cravings.

New Pie Co, Toronto#6
Why it stands out

  • Cute spot with creative flavors, but the crust could benefit from more sugar.

  • Delicious pies with addicting flavors and fantastic crust.

  • Amazing pies with refreshing and unique flavors, such as Ube, mochi, and chocolate pumpkin.

New Pie Co

4.649 reviews
1561 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6K 1T8, Canada

New Pie Co is a beloved bakery in Toronto that offers a variety of unique and culturally diverse pies. The bakery provides different service options such as no-contact delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway. Customers can enjoy delicious pies with a rating of 4.6 in a cozy and inviting atmosphere.

Customers praise the owner of New Pie Co for the delightful experience and the high-quality ingredients used in making the pies. Whether you are a pie enthusiast or looking for a special dessert for an occasion, New Pie Co is the perfect place to satisfy your sweet cravings.

Sharman's Proper Pies, Toronto#7
Why it stands out

  • Steak & Cheese / Steak & Ale pies are excellent tasting.

  • Chicken balti and Steak and cheese pies are recommended, with the steak pie being the better option.

  • Sausage rolls and Spicy Jerk pie are especially delicious, catering to different flavor preferences.

  • The lack of seasoning in tourtieres and the lack of customer service response from the bakery were areas of disappointment for some customers.

Sharman's Proper Pies

4.5119 reviews
1972 Danforth Ave, Toronto, ON M4C 1J6, Canada

Sharman's Proper Pies is a beloved bakery located in Toronto, Canada. They offer a variety of service options, including kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, and in-store shopping. The bakery is wheelchair-accessible and LGBTQ+ friendly. Customers can pay with credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

With a 4.5 rating and 119 reviews, Sharman's Proper Pies has garnered a loyal following. Customers have praised their pies for being delicious, flavorful, and high quality. Some key points from customer reviews include:

Visit Sharman's Proper Pies for a delightful bakery experience and indulge in their scrumptious offerings!

Wanda's Pie in the Sky, Toronto#8
Why it stands out

  • The cherry pie is a must-try, with actual cherries and the right balance of sweetness.

  • The Peanut Butter Mousse cake was a delightful experience from start to finish, perfect for special occasions.

  • The Wild Blueberry Pie received praise for its delicious filling and flaky crust.

  • Some customers found the pies overly sweet but appreciated the unique flavors and cozy atmosphere of the bakery.

Wanda's Pie in the Sky

4.31,627 reviews
287 Augusta Ave, Toronto, ON M5T 2M2, Canada

Wanda's Pie in the Sky is a charming bakery located in Toronto that offers a variety of service options, including in-store pick-up, takeaway, and dine-in. The bakery is known for its delicious pies, cheesecakes, cakes, and more. Customers have raved about their experiences, highlighting a few key points:

With a rating of 4.3 based on 1627 reviews, Wanda's Pie in the Sky continues to delight customers with its delectable treats and welcoming ambiance. Next time you're in the area, make sure to stop by for a slice of pie or a sweet indulgence.

Bobbette & Belle Artisanal Pastries, Toronto#9
Why it stands out

  • The scones are a must-try and are incredibly delicious

  • The pastries are large in size and not overly sweet, perfect for a delightful treat

  • The staff is friendly, welcoming, and provides excellent recommendations

  • The coffee and Americano are smooth and delicious, complementing the tasty treats perfectly

Bobbette & Belle Artisanal Pastries

4.3815 reviews
1121 Queen St E, Toronto, ON M4M 1K9, Canada

Bobbette & Belle Artisanal Pastries is a charming bakery located in Toronto. The business offers a variety of services such as delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and takeaway. Accessibility features include a wheelchair-accessible entrance and toilet, making it inclusive for all customers.

Customers rave about the delectable pastries and delightful ambiance of the bakery. Some key points from the reviews include:

Whether you're looking for a peaceful place to unwind with a latte and pastry or craving a rich, fruity cupcake, Bobbette & Belle Artisanal Pastries is the ideal spot to satisfy your cravings.

The Rolling Pin, Toronto#10
Why it stands out

  • A customer delightedly shared their experience of creating a cupcake flower bouquet for a bridal shower, praising the creativity allowed by the bakery.

  • Another customer commended the friendly staff and excellent customer service, along with the delicious assortment of donuts.

  • One reviewer expressed disappointment in the dryness of the donuts and sweetness of the toppings but appreciated the friendly customer service.

  • A satisfied customer praised the bakery for their outstanding custom cakes, describing them as delicious and beautifully designed, with top-notch ordering and communication.

The Rolling Pin

4.3712 reviews
1970 Avenue Rd, North York, ON M5M 4A1, Canada

The Rolling Pin is a renowned bakery in North York, Canada, offering a wide range of delicious treats and cakes. They provide in-store pick-up and takeaway options for their customers' convenience. The bakery also offers accessible facilities like wheelchair-accessible car park and wheelchair-accessible entrance.

With a high rating of 4.3 stars and numerous reviews, The Rolling Pin has established itself as a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

These customer reviews showcase the bakery's commitment to delivering top-quality products and exceptional service. Visit The Rolling Pin to experience their delectable treats and personalized cakes for yourself!

Sweetie Pie (Distillery District), Toronto#11
Why it stands out

  • A small pie house with a wide array of pie flavors that are difficult to resist. The blueberry pie is a must-try!

  • Delicious savory pies with perfectly buttery crusts that are heavenly. Service is exceptional and patient while helping customers make decisions.

  • Lemon meringue pie and cookies were delightful, with well-done crusts. Plenty of seating available for in-store dining.

  • A great selection of pies and butter tarts, but cookies fell short of expectations. Disappointing cookies aside, the service was pleasant and friendly with ample seating.

Sweetie Pie (Distillery District)

4.5139 reviews
6 Case Goods Lane, Toronto, ON M5A 3C4, Canada

Sweetie Pie (Distillery District) is a charming bakery located in Toronto, Canada. This cozy spot offers a variety of service options such as delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and takeaway. The bakery is known for its delectable pies, savory and sweet, along with scrumptious cookies and ice cream.

Customers have raved about their experience at Sweetie Pie:

Don't miss out on the opportunity to visit Sweetie Pie (Distillery District) for a delightful treat that will satisfy your sweet tooth cravings.

Sweetie Pie (Leaside), Toronto#12
Why it stands out

  • Bella the cashier provided exceptional customer service.

  • The mushroom savoury pie is phenomenal and reasonably priced.

  • Customers enjoyed the helpful service, amazing products, and open hours, making it a favorite spot for future visits.

  • The store has a pleasant smell, and the ice cream is a delightful treat, especially during hot weather.

Sweetie Pie (Leaside)

4.623 reviews
1639 Bayview Ave, East York, ON M4G 3B5, Canada

Sweetie Pie (Leaside) is a charming bakery located in East York, Canada. The bakery offers a variety of service options including delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and takeaway. Customers can enjoy the convenience of NFC mobile payments and debit cards for easy transactions.

With a 4.6 rating and 23 reviews, Sweetie Pie (Leaside) has garnered positive feedback from customers. Some key points from the reviews include:

Whether you're craving a delicious pie, cookie, or tart, Sweetie Pie (Leaside) is the place to visit for high-quality baked goods and outstanding customer service.

Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop, Toronto#13
Why it stands out

  • Nice bakery with freshly baked breads, pastries, cakes, and more

  • Wide variety of products, including additional items like cards, gift items, and napkins

  • Delicious and not too sweet chocolate cheesecake loved by all

  • Quick service, reasonable prices, and a good selection of soups, breads, and sweets

Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop

4.5407 reviews
420 Eglinton Ave W, Toronto, ON M5N 1A2, Canada

Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop is a beloved bakery located in Toronto, Canada, offering a wide array of delicious treats and baked goods. With a rating of 4.5 stars, it is clear that customers appreciate the quality and taste of the products offered.

Whether you're looking for a special dessert for a celebration or just want to treat yourself, Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop has something for everyone. Stop by for some freshly baked goodies or order for delivery or in-store pick-up!

Sweetie Pie (First Canadian Place), Toronto#14
Why it stands out

  • Delicious cupcakes that are moist and not too sweet

  • Decadent chocolate bourbon pecan pie and tender beef short rib

  • Massive and delicious cookies, with the Oreo one being a favorite

  • Wide selection of treats including amazing butter tarts and cookies

Sweetie Pie (First Canadian Place)

4.119 reviews
100 King St W, Toronto, ON M5X 1A9, Canada

Sweetie Pie (First Canadian Place) is a charming bakery located in Toronto, offering a variety of delectable treats. The business provides delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway options for customer convenience. Customers can indulge in their favorite goodies by simply visiting the website or giving them a call.

With a rating of 4.1, customers have raved about the mouth-watering selection at Sweetie Pie. Here are a few key points from customer reviews:

Visit Sweetie Pie today to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings!

Pie Squared, Toronto#15
Why it stands out

  • The beef/cheese and Guinness pies are flavorful and satisfying.

  • The jerk chicken pie is phenomenally flavorful with just the right amount of spice.

  • The crust is flaky and the pies are packed with different levels of flavor, made from the heart.

  • The chicken pot pie is a standout, authentic British pub fare done right.

Pie Squared

4.1110 reviews
nan

Pie Squared is a beloved pie shop in Toronto that offers a unique twist on traditional pies. Customers can enjoy a variety of savory and sweet pies made with fresh ingredients and packed with delicious flavors. The shop also offers delivery service for those who prefer enjoying their pies at home.

With a rating of 4.1 based on 110 reviews, Pie Squared continues to delight customers with its delicious pies and friendly service. Whether you're craving a savory pie or a sweet treat, Pie Squared is the place to visit for a delightful culinary experience.

Kensington Natural Bakery, Toronto#16
Why it stands out

  • I love the combination of an old fashioned coffee shop with modern gluten-free offerings. The atmosphere is unpretentious and authentically '90s.

  • The prices are a lot better than trendy gluten-free places, and the food tastes wholesome and handmade.

  • They have vegan, gluten-free, sugar-free, and eggless cake options, perfect for special occasions.

  • The bakery has a cozy and quiet atmosphere, making it a great spot for relaxing, studying, or enjoying a cup of coffee.

Kensington Natural Bakery

4.0130 reviews
460 Bloor St W, Toronto, ON M5S 1X8, Canada

Kensington Natural Bakery is a charming bakery located in Toronto that offers a variety of options for their customers. Some of the service options provided include delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway. The bakery is known for its gluten-free offerings and authentic atmosphere that customers appreciate.

Customers have left positive reviews for Kensington Natural Bakery, highlighting a few key points:

The essentials in one table

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1Sweet Trolley Bakery 4.8263
#2The Pie Commission 4.71,044
#3Dough Bakeshop 4.6241
#4Sweetie Pie (Harbord) 4.6163
#5Sweetie Pie (Queen St.) 4.665
#6New Pie Co 4.649
#7Sharman's Proper Pies 4.5119
#8Wanda's Pie in the Sky 4.31,627
#9Bobbette & Belle Artisanal Pastries 4.3815
#10The Rolling Pin 4.3712
#11Sweetie Pie (Distillery District) 4.5139
#12Sweetie Pie (Leaside) 4.623
#13Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop 4.5407
#14Sweetie Pie (First Canadian Place) 4.119
#15Pie Squared 4.1110
#16Kensington Natural Bakery 4.0130

Business owner or manager?

List or claim my business

Map of Pumpkin Pies in Toronto

Ready to go on a quest for the perfect pumpkin pie in Toronto? We've got you covered! Here is a comprehensive map of all the pumpkin pie spots in the city. From classic diners to fancy pastry shops, find out where you can satisfy your autumnal craving in Toronto.

How to compare Pumpkin Pies in Toronto

  1. Location: Find the most conveniently located bakeries for you.
  2. Price Range: Compare prices to find a pie that fits your budget.
  3. Variety: Discover the vast array of pumpkin pie variations.
  4. Dietary Options: Whether you need gluten-free, vegan, or nut-free, candy can be found in the list.
  5. Reviews: See what other pumpkin pie enthusiasts say about the pies.

Your questions answered

Where can I find the best pumpkin pie in Toronto?

If you're looking for the best pumpkin pie in Toronto, there are several bakeries and cafes that are known for their delicious and flavorful versions of this classic fall dessert. Some popular places to consider include Uncle Tetsu's Bake Shop, Sweet Olenka's, and Wanda's Pie in the Sky. These establishments are known for their high-quality ingredients and expert baking techniques that result in pies that are both tasty and visually appealing. Another option is to visit a local farmers' market in Toronto during the fall season. Many vendors at these markets offer homemade pumpkin pies made with freshly harvested pumpkins and other local ingredients. This can be a great way to support small businesses and enjoy a pie that is truly farm-to-table.

Are there any vegan or gluten-free pumpkin pie options in Toronto?

For those with dietary restrictions or preferences, Toronto offers a variety of vegan and gluten-free pumpkin pie options. Popular bakeries and cafes that cater to these dietary needs include Bunners Bake Shop, Through Being Cool Bakery, and Doomie's Toronto. These establishments offer pumpkin pies that are free from animal products and gluten, making them suitable for vegans, those with gluten sensitivities, or anyone looking for a healthier alternative. Additionally, many health food stores in Toronto carry pre-made vegan and gluten-free pumpkin pies that you can enjoy at home. These pies are often made with nutritional ingredients like coconut milk and almond flour to create a delicious and healthy dessert option.

Can I order a custom pumpkin pie for a special occasion in Toronto?

Yes, many bakeries and cafes in Toronto offer the option to order custom pumpkin pies for special occasions such as birthdays, holidays, or other celebrations. Whether you're looking for a traditional pumpkin pie, a vegan or gluten-free version, or a unique flavor twist on the classic dessert, most establishments are happy to accommodate your needs. When ordering a custom pumpkin pie, it's important to provide advance notice to the bakery or cafe to ensure they have enough time to prepare your pie to your specifications. You may also have the option to customize the size, shape, and toppings of the pie to make it truly special for the occasion.

What is the average price range for pumpkin pie in Toronto?

The price range for pumpkin pie in Toronto can vary depending on where you purchase it and whether you opt for a standard or premium version. On average, a single slice of pumpkin pie at a bakery or cafe may cost between $4 to $6, while a whole pie can range from $20 to $40 depending on the size and ingredients used. If you choose to order a custom pumpkin pie for a special occasion, the price may be slightly higher due to the personalized nature of the dessert. However, many bakeries and cafes in Toronto offer competitive pricing and special discounts for bulk orders or frequent customers.

Other related guides

The 8 Best Japanese Grocery Stores in TorontoThe 5 Best Sufganiyot in TorontoThe 14 Best Breweries in Toronto