Menu

The 15 Best Custom Cakes in Toronto

Looking for custom cakes in Toronto? Crafting the perfect cake isn't just about taste, but involves a fusion of distinct flavors, artistic design themes, and superb craftsmanship that mirror your unique style and taste.

Here, you can explore a list of the best places offering custom cake services in Toronto. Browse through their offerings and find the one that meets your specific needs and preferences.

Comparison is vital; that's why we've curated this comprehensive list for you. Dive in and discover the best provider for your custom cake needs in Toronto.

How this list is ordered

Before ranking this guide we review each business's track record, what its customers say and how clearly it explains its work. The result is an editorial selection that we update as things change.

Featured positions are clearly marked and only offered to businesses that already earned their place in the guide.

Top 3Every optionMapChoosing well

Where to start

Pick one to read the short summary below.

#1
I Do! Wedding Cakes
5.0157 reviews
#2
The Flower Cake Café
4.8152 reviews
#3
Finespun Cakes & Pastries
5.043 reviews

Compare the 15 local options

I Do! Wedding Cakes, Toronto#1
Why it stands out

  • The owner was a dream to work with, from transparent pricing to flawless execution.

  • The cakes were stunning, matched inspirations perfectly, and tasted amazing with many flavor options.

  • The intricate designs, attention to detail, and accommodating nature of the owner received many compliments from guests.

  • The personalized service, exquisite cakes, and exceptional customer service made special occasions memorable.

I Do! Wedding Cakes

5.0157 reviews
Glencairn Ave, North York, ON M6B 1Z4, Canada

I Do! Wedding Cakes is a renowned wedding bakery that offers a variety of service options to cater to every couple's needs. Whether it's kerbside pickup, online appointments, delivery, or takeaway, they have it all. Appointment is required for planning, ensuring a personalized experience for each client.

Customers have left glowing reviews for I Do! Wedding Cakes. Here are some key points from their feedback:

If you're looking for a wedding cake that is not only visually stunning but also delicious, I Do! Wedding Cakes is the perfect choice. Their attention to detail and personalized service make every cake unique and unforgettable.

The Flower Cake Café, Toronto#2
Why it stands out

  • Customers love the quaint and cozy vibes of the café, making it a perfect place to relax and enjoy delicious desserts.

  • The diverse menu includes fancy cakes, piped flower cupcakes, croissants, sandwiches, and more, catering to a wide range of tastes.

  • Reviewers appreciate the friendly and helpful staff, adding to the overall enjoyable experience at the café.

The Flower Cake Café

4.8152 reviews
20 St Patrick St, Toronto, ON M5T 2Y4, Canada

The Flower Cake Café is a delightful dessert shop located in a cozy corner of St Patrick St, Toronto. This charming café offers a variety of service options, including delivery and in-store pick-up, making it convenient for customers to enjoy their treats.

With a stellar rating of 4.8, based on 152 reviews, customers rave about the café's offerings. Here are some key points from the reviews:

Whether you're in the mood for a decadent dessert or a savory treat, The Flower Cake Café is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered in downtown Toronto. Don't miss out on the opportunity to indulge in their delightful offerings!

Finespun Cakes & Pastries, Toronto#3
Why it stands out

  • The custom cake was delicious and well-enjoyed by guests.

  • Professionalism, easy collaboration, and stunning cake design were highlighted.

  • Gorgeous and delicious cakes that impressed both visually and in taste.

  • Excellent communication, refined flavors, and beautiful cake designs.

Finespun Cakes & Pastries

5.043 reviews
970 Bathurst St, Toronto, ON M5R 3G6, Canada

Finespun Cakes & Pastries is a renowned wedding bakery in Toronto that offers a wide range of services and features. Customers rave about the exquisite cakes and pastries created by the talented team. Some key points from customer reviews include:

This establishment stands out for its attention to detail, creative designs, and exquisite flavors, making it a top choice for those seeking a memorable and delectable wedding cake.

Another Slice, Toronto#4
Why it stands out

  • The cakes are not only visually stunning but also delicious, exceeding customers' expectations.

  • The pricing is reasonable, making custom cakes more accessible for everyone.

  • Wafa's professionalism, responsiveness, and ability to bring ideas to life through her cakes are highly praised.

Another Slice

4.949 reviews
320 Richmond St E, Toronto, ON M5A 1P9, Canada

Another Slice is a top-tier cake shop located in Toronto that offers a wide range of exquisite custom cakes for various occasions. Customers rave about the exceptional quality of the cakes and the personalized service they receive. The business provides a variety of service options such as kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, and in-store pick-up to cater to different customer needs.

Whether you're looking for a unique birthday cake, custom cookies for a special event, or a thematic cake for a celebration, Another Slice is the perfect choice for all your custom cake needs in Toronto.

Frosted Flavors, Toronto#5
Why it stands out

  • Delightful cakes perfect for special occasions like Mother's Day and birthdays

  • Highly recommended for their signature chai teas and Portuguese custard tarts

  • Amazing custom cakes with moist and delicious flavors

  • Authentic Indian chai with just the right amount of spice and freshly made desserts

Frosted Flavors

4.7105 reviews
2198 A Queen St E, Toronto, ON M4E 1E7, Canada

Frosted Flavors is a delightful cake shop located in Toronto. They offer a variety of services such as kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, in-store shopping, and more. The shop is wheelchair-accessible and has a comfortable dine-in option. Customers rave about the beautiful cakes and friendly service at Frosted Flavors. Some key points from customer reviews include:

Whether you need a cake for a celebration or simply want to enjoy a treat, Frosted Flavors is the place to go.

Cozy Oven Cake Shop, Toronto#6
Why it stands out

  • Joy is professional, attentive, and brings visions to life with delicious cakes.

  • Cakes are not only beautiful but also consistently delicious and creatively decorated.

  • Customer service is exceptional and cakes are moist and flavorful, capturing requested themes perfectly.

  • Design process is fun and easy, cakes are moist, fluffy, and buttercream is to die for.

Cozy Oven Cake Shop

5.016 reviews
nan

Cozy Oven Cake Shop is a delightful cake shop that offers a variety of beautiful and delicious custom cakes. Their cakes are not only visually stunning but also incredibly tasty, with unique flavors that set them apart from competitors. Customers rave about the professionalism and attentiveness of Joy, the talented baker behind Cozy Oven. Here are some key points from the glowing reviews:

With a perfect rating of 5.0, Cozy Oven Cake Shop is a top choice for anyone looking for a custom cake that not only looks amazing but tastes incredible too!

Velvet Lane Cakes & Cafe, Toronto#7
Why it stands out

  • The aesthetic and cleanliness of the place create a calm vibe.

  • Customers appreciate the reasonable prices and the quality of the cakes.

  • Individuals rave about the friendly staff and the delicious pastries.

  • The custom cake orders exceed expectations and taste amazing.

Velvet Lane Cakes & Cafe

4.5247 reviews
173 King St E, Toronto, ON M5A 1J4, Canada

Velvet Lane Cakes & Cafe is a charming cake shop located in Toronto that offers a delightful selection of sweet treats. The business prides itself on providing a warm and welcoming environment for all customers. With a rating of 4.5 stars, it's clear that patrons have been thoroughly impressed with their experience.

Whether you're looking for a signature cake for a special occasion or simply want to indulge in a tasty pastry, Velvet Lane Cakes & Cafe is the place to visit.

The Grand Order of Divine Sweets, Toronto#8
Why it stands out

  • Cute and well-decorated place with amazing chocolates

  • High-quality custom cakes with great service and communication

  • Small cozy chocolate cafe with divine cakes and chocolates

  • Delicious and high-quality donuts in a clean, friendly environment

The Grand Order of Divine Sweets

4.5117 reviews
1162 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1J5, Canada

The Grand Order of Divine Sweets is a charming bakery located in Toronto, Canada. They offer a variety of services such as Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, Takeaway, and Dine-in. The bakery is known for its delicious cakes, chocolates, and donuts. Customers have left glowing reviews describing the place as cute, well-decorated, with great service, and amazing treats. Some key points from customer reviews include:

Whether you are looking for a sweet treat for yourself or a customized cake for a special occasion, The Grand Order of Divine Sweets is a top choice in Toronto for delightful baked goods.

It's the Icing on the Cake, Toronto#9
Why it stands out

  • A customer lamented about a disappointing experience with a personalized cake, citing poor communication and subpar quality. The cake did not meet expectations, with the personalized topper being particularly disappointing.

  • An elated customer drove from Scarborough for nut-free birthday cupcakes and praised the impeccable service received.

  • Customers expressed delight over custom birthday cakes that exceeded expectations in design and taste, with one customer commending Lynda as a "cake superstar."

  • Another customer highlighted the amazing wedding cake created by the bakery, mentioning its exquisite appearance and delicious taste that left guests raving.

It's the Icing on the Cake

4.595 reviews
1238 Queen St E, Toronto, ON M4L 1C3, Canada

It's the Icing on the Cake is a renowned cake shop located in Toronto, Canada, that offers a range of delectable treats for various occasions. The business provides delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway services, ensuring convenience for all customers. Moreover, the bakery is fully accessible, with features like a wheelchair-accessible car park and entrance.

With a stellar rating of 4.5 stars from 95 reviews, the bakery has garnered a loyal customer base who have shared rave feedback. Here are some key points from their reviews:

The glowing reviews coupled with the diverse service offerings make It's the Icing on the Cake a top choice for anyone looking to elevate their celebration with a scrumptious treat.

Vanilla Bite Bakery, Toronto#10
Why it stands out

  • The gluten-free cakes are described as beautiful, delicious, and unique.

  • Customers praise the bakery for accommodating special dietary needs, such as gluten-free options.

  • The cakes are not overly sweet and are moist, making them a hit with everyone.

  • The personalized service and attention to detail are highly appreciated by customers.

Vanilla Bite Bakery

4.7168 reviews
389 Front St W, Toronto, ON M5V 3R9, Canada

Vanilla Bite Bakery is a charming bakery in Toronto that offers a delightful selection of treats. Customers rave about the gluten-free options and the exceptional customer service they receive. The bakery offers delivery services, including no-contact delivery, making it convenient for customers to enjoy their delicious treats.

To Bakes, Toronto#11
Why it stands out

  • The cakes are not only beautiful but also incredibly tasty, making them perfect for birthdays and special occasions.

  • Customers praise the excellent customer service, describing the staff as friendly, efficient, and accommodating.

  • Many customers appreciate the convenience of being able to order cakes and balloons in one place, streamlining the party planning process.

  • Overall, customers highly recommend To Bakes for anyone looking for delicious cakes and top-notch service.

To Bakes

5.09 reviews
51 Jefferson Ave UNIT 101, Toronto, ON M6K 1Y3, Canada

To Bakes is a popular cake shop in Toronto that offers a variety of delicious cakes for any occasion. Customers can enjoy the convenience of delivery, in-store pick-up, or takeaway options. The shop accepts payment via credit cards, making transactions quick and easy.

With a perfect rating of 5.0 stars, customers are raving about To Bakes. Here are some key points from the reviews:

The Rolling Pin, Toronto#12
Why it stands out

  • The cupcake bouquets are a hit, making baking look easy and fun for everyone. Customers appreciate the creativity and freedom to customize their designs.

  • Despite being a cash or debit only establishment, the staff is praised for being friendly and providing excellent customer service.

  • While some customers may have found the donuts to be a bit lacking in flavor, others swear by the unique and delicious offerings, especially the blueberry cheesecake and Nutella flavors.

  • The custom cakes are a standout feature, with many customers returning for more due to the delicious taste and beautiful designs.

The Rolling Pin

4.3712 reviews
1970 Avenue Rd, North York, ON M5M 4A1, Canada

The Rolling Pin is a beloved bakery in North York known for its delicious treats and exceptional customer service. Customers rave about the variety and quality of the baked goods available. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

With a rating of 4.3 out of 5, The Rolling Pin is a must-visit for anyone looking to satisfy their sweet tooth with high-quality baked goods.

Wedding Cakes By Helena, Toronto#13
Why it stands out

  • Helena guided customers through a variety of cake designs, creating a stunning buttercream cake that was both visually appealing and delicious.

  • Customers highly recommend Helena for her creativity and expertise in crafting delicious cakes, like a 3-tier orange chiffon cake with buttercream that left them coming back for more.

  • Her impeccable designs and friendly service make every experience with Wedding Cakes By Helena a delightful one.

Wedding Cakes By Helena

5.06 reviews
11 Stephenson Ave, Toronto, ON M4C 1E9, Canada

Wedding Cakes By Helena is a top-notch wedding service located in Toronto, Canada. Known for their exquisite cakes and exceptional service, customers rave about their experience with Helena. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

With a 5.0 rating and glowing testimonials, Wedding Cakes By Helena continues to delight customers with their personalized service and delectable creations. Visit their website to explore more of Helena's masterpieces and make your special day even sweeter.

Bake Shoppe, Toronto#14
Why it stands out

  • Delicious cookies and friendly staff!

  • Red velvet cupcakes are a must-try!

  • Cute bakery with unique treats like customized cookies.

  • Beautiful desserts, delicious treats, and friendly staff!

Bake Shoppe

4.3201 reviews
Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1Y5, Canada

Bake Shoppe is a charming bakery located in Toronto, offering a variety of delectable treats and goodies. Customers rave about their flavorful pastries, cupcakes, cookies, and custom cakes. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

With a rating of 4.3 stars, Bake Shoppe prides itself on providing top-notch service and scrumptious baked goods. Whether you're stopping by for a quick treat or placing an order for a special occasion, this bakery is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Metro Bakery, Toronto#15
Why it stands out

  • Best piece of pastry ever. This butter maple flavored pecan twist is absolutely delicious beyond expectation. Not overly sweet and the texture and smell perfect.

  • You need a cake right away they got your back. Flakey croissants are really good. Even better if you pop them back in the oven for 5min. Apple cake is to die for, maybe not die. But the cake is very delicious. Can't go wrong with their muffins.

  • I have typically enjoyed most of the desserts I have purchased from this brand, however their holiday-themed confections are definitely below standard.

  • The 'All Butter Icebox Cookies' in particular taste like egg-flavored bile, and most Metro stores have no qualms about displaying bakery products that are well past their expiration date -- a consumer hazard. I really did enjoy a lot of selections by this Bakery, save for the newer problems I've encountered, so I hope that quality improvements can be made in the new year.

Metro Bakery

4.124 reviews
80 Front St E, Toronto, ON M5E 1T4, Canada

Metro Bakery is a beloved establishment in Toronto, known for its delectable pastries, cakes, and cookies. Customers rave about the variety of treats available and the fresh quality of all items. The bakery offers convenient Takeaway options, making it easy to grab a snack on the go. Accessibility is also a priority, with a Wheelchair-accessible entrance for all patrons. Credit cards are accepted for payment, adding to the overall convenience of the experience.

The essentials in one table

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1I Do! Wedding Cakes 5.0157
#2The Flower Cake Café 4.8152
#3Finespun Cakes & Pastries 5.043
#4Another Slice 4.949
#5Frosted Flavors 4.7105
#6Cozy Oven Cake Shop 5.016
#7Velvet Lane Cakes & Cafe 4.5247
#8The Grand Order of Divine Sweets 4.5117
#9It's the Icing on the Cake 4.595
#10Vanilla Bite Bakery 4.7168
#11To Bakes 5.09
#12The Rolling Pin 4.3712
#13Wedding Cakes By Helena 5.06
#14Bake Shoppe 4.3201
#15Metro Bakery 4.124

Business owner or manager?

List or claim my business

Map of Custom Cakes in Toronto

Explore the best places to get your perfect dessert in Canada's bustling metropolis with our comprehensive Map of Custom Cakes Toronto. Each location specializes in creating unique, personalized cakes that elevate any celebration. Dive into Toronto’s sweet culinary scene and find the bakery that resonates with your taste.

How to compare Custom Cakes in Toronto

  1. Range of Flavours: Each bakery has a unique array of flavors and fillings to offer.
  2. Diverse Design Themes: Do they provide creative and innovative design themes? The choice might depend on your theme.
  3. Size Options: Depending on the size of your event, the right service should meet your specific size requirements.
  4. Delivery: A key factor would be their delivery service - can they deliver anywhere in Toronto on time? Customer reviews: Don't forget to check out their customer reviews for insights on their taste and service quality.

Your questions answered

What are the benefits of ordering custom cakes in Toronto?

When you order a custom cake in Toronto, you have the opportunity to personalize every aspect of your dessert. This means you can choose the flavors, fillings, and decorations that best suit your taste and occasion. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, wedding, or corporate event, a custom cake allows you to make a unique statement that reflects your personality and style. Additionally, custom cakes in Toronto are typically made with high-quality ingredients and attention to detail. Professional bakers and decorators can create intricate designs and intricate details that you won't find in store-bought cakes. This ensures that your custom cake not only looks stunning but also tastes delicious.

How far in advance should I order a custom cake in Toronto?

It's recommended to order a custom cake in Toronto as far in advance as possible to secure your spot with a professional baker. Depending on the intricacy of the design and the availability of the baker, some may require a minimum notice of one to two weeks, while others may need even more time for complex orders. To ensure that your custom cake is ready on time for your event, it's best to inquire with the bakery about their ordering policies and availability. Planning ahead and providing clear instructions will help the baker create the perfect custom cake that meets your expectations.

What factors should I consider when choosing a custom cake bakery in Toronto?

When selecting a bakery for your custom cake in Toronto, there are several important factors to consider. First and foremost, look for a bakery with a good reputation for creating delicious and beautifully decorated cakes. Reading reviews and looking at photos of their past work can help you gauge the quality of their products. It's also important to consider the bakery's pricing, availability, and delivery options. Make sure to communicate your preferences, dietary restrictions, and any specific design ideas you have in mind to ensure that the bakery can accommodate your needs. Finally, choose a bakery that offers excellent customer service and is willing to work closely with you to bring your custom cake vision to life.

Can I request custom cakes with special dietary restrictions in Toronto?

Many bakeries in Toronto offer custom cakes that cater to special dietary restrictions, such as gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan, or nut-free options. If you have specific dietary requirements, make sure to communicate them clearly with the bakery when placing your order. Some bakeries may have limited options for special dietary restrictions, while others specialize in creating delicious custom cakes for various dietary needs. When requesting a custom cake with special dietary restrictions, it's important to inquire about the ingredients used and any potential cross-contamination risks. By doing so, you can enjoy a beautiful and delicious custom cake that meets your dietary needs and tastes just as good as traditional cakes.

Other related guides

The 16 Best Ice Cream Spots in TorontoThe 15 Best Sausages in TorontoThe 15 Best Pancakes in Toronto