The 16 Best Italian Restaurants in Downtown Toronto

Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Front Street offers a delightful experience for those craving authentic Italian cuisine in Toronto. With a diverse menu featuring pasta, pizza, wine, and beer, customers are sure to find something they love. The cozy ambiance and attentive staff create a welcoming atmosphere for patrons to enjoy a meal with family or friends.

• The food is excellent, with homemade pasta and cheese that are fresh and flavorful.
• The staff is friendly and the service is quick and efficient.
• The portions are generous and the prices offer good value for the quality of food served.
• The atmosphere is upscale yet cozy, making every visit a memorable experience.

Whether it's for a casual lunch or a special dinner, Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Front Street is a great choice for anyone looking to savor the taste of Italy in a comfortable setting.

Gusto 101 is an acclaimed Italian restaurant located in Toronto. This dining spot offers a variety of services to its patrons, including delivery, dine-in, takeaway, and outdoor seating. The highlights of Gusto 101 include its great cocktails and rooftop seating, creating a unique and enjoyable atmosphere for customers.

Customer reviews of Gusto 101 highlight the following key points:

• Polite and friendly service with great-tasting food, although could have been warmer.
• Quick service and good dishes, especially during happy hour.
• Consistently delicious food with lovely service, particularly recommended for brunch and group gatherings.
• Great quality food served promptly, highly recommended for reservations.

Terroni is a renowned Italian restaurant located in Toronto, Canada. Offering a wide array of services including Outdoor seating, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in, Terroni ensures that customers have a delightful dining experience. The highlights of this restaurant include Fast service, a charming Fireplace, and tantalizing Great cocktails.

• Terroni Adelaide location is incredible in all aspects. Customers rave about the delicious pizza, impeccable service, and the historic ambiance.
• Guests appreciate the unique atmosphere of the restaurant, set in a former court house, and enjoy the gourmet southern Italian cuisine.
• Many patrons commend the friendly staff, excellent recommendations, and the delectable pizzas and desserts. They particularly love the Gelato flavors, hazelnut, and pistachio.

Eataly Toronto is a renowned Italian restaurant located in the heart of Toronto, offering a delightful culinary experience through its array of restaurants and variety of food options. The Italian food market within the establishment is a treat for the senses, providing a wide selection of high-quality ingredients and products. The staff at Eataly Toronto is known for their friendly service, adding to the overall pleasant atmosphere. While some customers may find the prices to be on the higher side, the quality of the food is commendable.

• Eataly Toronto offers a variety of different types of food and pastries.
• Customers appreciate the high-quality ingredients and products available at the Italian food market.
• The friendly staff and pleasant atmosphere enhance the dining experience.
• Some visitors find the prices at Eataly Toronto to be on the higher side.

Piano Piano Restaurant is an Italian restaurant located in Toronto, Canada, known for its great service and delicious food. The restaurant offers a variety of service options such as outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers can enjoy a range of offerings including alcohol, beer, cocktails, coffee, small plates, spirits, vegetarian options, and wine.

The atmosphere at Piano Piano is described as cozy, romantic, and upmarket, making it a great spot for various occasions. Customers have praised the restaurant for being family-friendly, welcoming to groups, and LGBTQ+ friendly.

Some key points from customer reviews include:

• Great experience with lunch menu, amazing mains, and perfect Tiramisu.
• Good price for filling lunch specials, slightly Americanized food but very delicious.
• Casual Italian place with nice options, friendly service but could be a bit more engaging.

Overall, Piano Piano Restaurant offers a delightful dining experience with a diverse menu, welcoming atmosphere, and attentive service.

Carisma is an exquisite Italian restaurant located in Toronto, offering a variety of services and amenities to ensure a memorable dining experience. The restaurant provides options for takeaway, dine-in, and even features bar on site and toilets for added convenience.

With a rating of 4.4 stars from 1098 reviews, customers have raved about their experiences at Carisma. Some key points from these reviews include:

• This restaurant serves absolutely delicious food, with a standout dish being the Spaghettini with tiger shrimp.
• Customers praise the professional and friendly service provided by the staff.
• The elegant and romantic ambiance of the restaurant adds to the overall dining experience.

Customers have highlighted the warm welcoming, comfortable seating, and formal interior of the restaurant, creating a charismatic atmosphere. Visitors have enjoyed dishes like vegetable specials, lasagna, and homemade truffle pasta, all paired with exceptional service.

For those looking for an authentic Italian dining experience in a classic and chic setting, Carisma comes highly recommended. Book your reservation today and indulge in the finest Italian cuisine Toronto has to offer.

Cafe Diplomatico Restaurant & Pizzeria is a charming Italian restaurant located in Toronto, Canada. This popular spot offers a variety of service options such as outdoor seating, kerbside pickup, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Known for its fast service and great cocktails, Cafe Diplomatico is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Customers have left glowing reviews about their experiences at Cafe Diplomatico. Here are a few key points summarized from their reviews:

• The pizza is a standout dish with a crispy thin crust and mouthwatering toppings.
• The cozy atmosphere of the restaurant creates a welcoming and homey vibe.
• The menu offers a variety of options, including the ability to create your own pizza and choose different pasta types.
• Service is top-notch, with efficient and friendly staff ensuring a pleasant dining experience.

With a rating of 4.2 stars, Cafe Diplomatico Restaurant & Pizzeria is a must-visit destination for those craving authentic Italian cuisine in a relaxed and inviting setting.

Sud Forno is a renowned restaurant located in Toronto, Canada, offering a variety of dining options and amenities to cater to its diverse clientele. The establishment boasts a charming atmosphere, blending casual and upscale elements, making it ideal for various occasions.

Customers have raved about their experiences at Sud Forno, highlighting several key points:

• Great cocktails and friendly staff
• Delicious food with reasonable prices
• Visually appealing environment with a relaxing vibe
• Excellent service and efficient staff

One satisfied patron praised the establishment for its chic sophistication and diverse menu offerings, noting the exceptional quality of the coffee and pastries. Another customer emphasized the restaurant's bread and olive oil as standout appetizers, perfect for hanging out with friends.

Most reviewers have rated Sud Forno positively, citing its overall pleasant experience and delicious food. Whether craving a quick bite or a full dining experience, Sud Forno promises a memorable culinary journey for all its patrons.

Donatello Restaurant brings the flavors of Italy to Toronto with a cozy and romantic atmosphere that is perfect for families, groups, and LGBTQ+ patrons. The menu offers a variety of traditional Italian dishes, including homemade tiramisu and a secret lobster pasta not found on the regular menu. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes, attentive service, and reasonable prices. With options for outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in, Donatello Restaurant caters to all preferences. So whether you're craving a hearty pasta dish or a refreshing cocktail, this Italian restaurant has something for everyone.

• Ambiance is cozy and romantic
• Generous portion sizes
• Reasonable prices
• Attentive and friendly service

ARDO Restaurant is a cozy restaurant located in Toronto that offers a variety of services and features to enhance the dining experience. The restaurant provides kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options for customers. Additionally, guests can enjoy great cocktails as one of the highlights of the place.

• A customer had a delicious dinner with friends, enjoying special pizza, scallops, and cocktails, followed by tasty pastas and gnocchi.
• Another diner appreciated the great food, sparkling drinks, and friendly service, recommending the pizza, beef dishes, brasato, panna cotta, and acciughe.
• An individual praised the incredible Italian food at ARDO, highlighting the fantastic flatbread pizza and pastas.

With a solid rating of 4.4 based on 697 reviews, ARDO Restaurant has garnered positive feedback from customers, making it a must-try spot for Italian cuisine enthusiasts in Toronto.

Biagio Ristorante is a renowned Italian restaurant located in Toronto. The restaurant offers a variety of service options including outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. For those requiring accessibility, they have wheelchair-accessible entrance, seating, and toilet. Customers can enjoy a range of offerings such as alcohol, cocktails, coffee, and wine. Biagio Ristorante provides a cozy, romantic, and upmarket atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for different occasions.

With a stellar rating of 4.5 out of 5, it's no surprise that Biagio Ristorante has garnered positive reviews. Here are a few key points from customer feedback:

• Authentic Italian cuisine
• Attentive service and knowledgeable staff
• Great food and wine recommendations

Experience top-notch Italian dishes and exceptional service at Biagio Ristorante, a perfect choice for a memorable dining experience.

La Fenice is an exquisite Italian restaurant located in Toronto, Canada, offering a variety of dining options. Customers can enjoy outdoor seating, kerbside pickup, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in services. The restaurant provides a cozy and romantic atmosphere, making it perfect for a variety of occasions. La Fenice offers a wide range of alcoholic beverages, cocktails, coffee, small plates, spirits, vegetarian options, and wine to complement the delicious menu.

With a rating of 4.4, this restaurant has received rave reviews from satisfied customers. Some key points from the reviews include:

• Great service and friendly staff
• Delicious food with generous portions
• Excellent seafood options on the menu
• Warm and enjoyable ambiance

One customer praised the exceptional service provided by their server Mario, while another highlighted the flavorful dishes like spicy shrimp linguine and agnolotti. Despite some mixed reviews regarding the food quality, La Fenice stands out for its wonderful ambience and attentive service. Visit La Fenice for a memorable Italian dining experience in the heart of Toronto.

La Bettola Di Terroni is an Italian restaurant located in Toronto that offers a range of services and features to enhance the dining experience. Whether you prefer outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, or dining in, this restaurant has got you covered. They provide a casual, cosy, romantic, and upmarket atmosphere for all types of diners.

Customer reviews rave about the delicious home-made pasta and fresh ingredients used in the dishes. The friendly staff and great service make it a perfect spot for a first date, date night, or even business meetings. The extensive wine selection and delightful main course pasta dishes have left customers coming back for more.

Here are a few summarized customer reviews:

• Delicious home-made pasta with fresh ingredients and great service. Ideal for date nights and business meetings. Not recommended for family dining.
• Cute and upscale atmosphere, quick service, but some mains were underwhelming. Pizza stands out as a favorite.
• Amazing parmigiana pizza and Burrata Ravioli. Quick service with no wait for a table. Highly recommended.
• Delicious food, superb wine, and wonderful service. Extensive wine selection and a phenomenal chef. Highly recommended.

Trattoria Mercatto is an authentic Italian restaurant located in Toronto, Canada. The restaurant offers various services including outdoor seating, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. Their menu includes a wide range of offerings such as beer, cocktails, vegan options, and wine. Customers can enjoy a casual and cosy atmosphere with groups of friends or family.

Customer reviews highlight the following key points:

• Fast and friendly service with a good variety on the menu
• Excellent homemade pasta dishes and seafood options
• Great Italian food in a bustling mall setting with friendly and efficient service
• Comfort food with affordable prices, pleasant ambiance, and great service

Mercatto is an iconic Italian restaurant located in the heart of Toronto, Canada. This gem offers a variety of services for its customers, including outdoor seating, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. The menu is diverse, offering delicious Italian dishes that are sure to leave you craving more.

Customer reviews rave about the amazing atmosphere and customer service at Mercatto. Some key points from the reviews include:

• Nice atmosphere with great customer service, recommended for office lunches and team gatherings.
• Food tasted delicious, service was on point, and the decor has a modern contemporary feel.
• Great atmosphere, very clean place, fresh food, and a range of tasty wines.
• Impeccable service, incredible flavors, cozy ambiance, and top-notch staff recommendations.

With a solid rating of 4.2 and numerous positive reviews, Mercatto is undoubtedly a top choice for those looking for an authentic Italian dining experience in Toronto. Visit their website for more information and make a reservation to enjoy a memorable meal at Mercatto.

Pizza Rustica is an inviting Italian restaurant nestled in the heart of Toronto. With a stellar rating of 3.6 based on 1095 reviews, it's a popular choice for locals and visitors alike.

• The friendly staff welcomes guests and offers helpful tips for exploring the city.
• The atmosphere is described as casual, making it a great spot for a chill night out.
• Customers rave about the delicious pasta dishes and fresh, hot pizzas served promptly.
• Some reviewers suggest calling ahead to verify the confusing hours of operation, especially for late-night cravings.

Whether you're craving a hearty pasta or a mouthwatering pizza, Pizza Rustica aims to satisfy your Italian cuisine desires. Visit their website for more information on their services and offerings!